Friday, September 30, 2011

Princeton goes open access to stop staff handing all copyright to journals – unless waiver granted

Prestigious US academic institution Princeton University will prevent researchers from giving the copyright of scholarly articles to journal publishers, except in certain cases where a waiver may be granted.

The new rule is part of an Open Access policy aimed at broadening the reach of their scholarly work and encouraging publishers to adjust standard contracts that commonly require exclusive copyright as a condition of publication.

Universities pay millions of dollars a year for academic journal subscriptions. People without subscriptions, which can cost up to $25,000 a year for some journals or hundreds of dollars for a single issue, are often prevented from reading taxpayer funded research. Individual articles are also commonly locked behind pay walls.

Researchers and peer reviewers are not paid for their work but academic publishers have said such a business model is required to maintain quality.

At a September 19 meeting, Princeton’s Faculty Advisory Committee on Policy adopted a new open access policy that gives the university the “nonexclusive right to make available copies of scholarly articles written by its faculty, unless a professor specifically requests a waiver for particular articles.”

“The University authorizes professors to post copies of their articles on their own web sites or on University web sites, or in other not-for-a-fee venues,” the policy said.

“The main effect of this new policy is to prevent them from giving away all their rights when they publish in a journal.”

Under the policy, academic staff will grant to The Trustees of Princeton University “a nonexclusive, irrevocable, worldwide license to exercise any and all copyrights in his or her scholarly articles published in any medium, whether now known or later invented, provided the articles are not sold by the University for a profit, and to authorise others to do the same.”

In cases where the journal refuses to publish their article without the academic handing all copyright to the publisher, the academic can seek a waiver from the open access policy from the University.

The policy authors acknowledged that this may make the rule toothless in practice but said open access policies can be used “to lean on the journals to adjust their standard contracts so that waivers are not required, or with a limited waiver that simply delays open access for a few months.”

Academics will also be encouraged to place their work in open access data stores such as Arxiv or campus-run data repositories.

Princeton University spokesman, Martin A. Mbugua, said the policy was not an outright ban on staff handing copyright to journal publishers.

“It is a new open access policy that gives our faculty an advantage, and the option of seeking a waiver,” he said.

A step forward

Having prestigious universities such as Princeton and Harvard fly the open access flag represented a step forward, said open access advocate Professor Simon Marginson from the University of Melbourne’s Centre for the Study of Higher Education.

“The achievement of free knowledge flows, and installation of open access publishing on the web as the primary form of publishing rather than oligopolistic journal publishing subject to price barriers, now depends on whether this movement spreads further among the peak research and scholarly institutions,” he said.

“Essentially, this approach – if it becomes general – normalises an open access regime and offers authors the option of opting out of that regime. This is a large improvement on the present position whereby copyright restrictions and price barriers are normal and authors have to attempt to opt in to open access publishing, or risk prosecution by posting their work in breach of copyright.”

“The only interests that lose out under the Princeton proposal are the big journal publishers. Everyone else gains.”

Professor Tom Cochrane, Deputy Vice-Chancellor Technology, Information and Learning Support at the Queensland University of Technology, who has also led an Open Access policy mandate at QUT welcomed Princeton’s new rule but warned that the waiver must not be used too regularly, lest the policy be undermined.

If all universities and research institutions globally had policies similar to Princeton’s, the ultimate owner of published academic work would be universities and their research communities collectively, Professor Cochrane said.

“They are the source of all the content that publishers absolutely require to run their business model,” he said.

Dr Danny Kingsley, an open access expert and Manager of Scholarly Communication and ePublishing at Australian National University said the move was a positive step and that the push for open access should come from the academic community.

In practice, however, the new policy requires staff have a good understanding of the copyright arrangements they currently have with journal publishers in their field.

They will need to ensure future publisher’s agreements accommodate the new position and if not, obtain a waiver from the University.

“This sounds easy but in reality might be a challenge for some academics. There is considerable evidence to show that academics often have very little understanding of the copyright situation of their published work,” she said.

“What will be most telling will be the publishers' response over the next year or so. If they start providing amended agreements to Princeton academics then the door will be open for other universities to follow this lead. I suspect however they will not, as generally the trend seems for publishers to make the open access path a complex and difficult one.”

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

Benching for Health Literature Searches

Email from Paula Clark, Health Services Research Librarian, Institute for Clinical Evaluative Sciences, Toronto, Ontario

I received many requests to post the responses for benchmarking literature searches in the health sciences, and I’m happy to share.

I didn’t receive or find a specific guidelines for establishing timelines/hours for a search, no doubt because of the variability of any search topic.

However PRESS (Peer Review of Electronic Search Strategies) is a tool recently developed by a team at CADTH (Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technology in Health) that provides a checklist to assess the quality of search strategies: http://www.cadth.ca/index.php/en/publication/781

Here are the responses:

- there may be a few studies that could be helpful. At one time I did what ship radio shack people do, and wrote down every 5 and 15 minute intervals what I did. (ship radio operators log every minute and every 5 minutes what they hear on the shortwaves.) Then produced a report as to what kinds of work I did, what the percentage was for the week of each activity. Also by having the time logged as well, you get a good idea of the heaviest times of the day (well, when the most requests come in.)
http://www.annals.org/content/144/10/742.full
http://www.rcjournal.com/contents/05.10/05.10.0578.pdf

- Both MLA and VALNET have done benchmarking. VALNET never differentiated in types of searches. We just counted searches.

- [re: MLA Benchmarking project] The last Benchmarking survey was published in 2008 and we would normally do another one in 2011. The Board will be discussing this at their meeting in October, but for now we have the 2008 data.

- I don’t know that you can benchmark actual hours spent/required, but you might be able to benchmark timelines. I work just on orthopaedic practice guidelines—fairly well-defined, right? But it is all over the map depending on the topic selected, limits, scope, etc. each work group decides on. However, for establishing the guideline development timetable, we regularly budget at least one month for the search and one month for the abstract review and article retrieval. Within that timeline, I might spend more or fewer hours each guideline, depending on the search parameters

And here is a list of resources I came across that were helpful/interesting:

MLA Benchmarking Network:

Website: http://www.mlanet.org/resources/benchmark07/definitions.html

Article: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1435860/

Library Activity Benchmarking Table : http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1435842/table/i1536-5050-094-02-0118-t01/
(taken from this report on the results of the MLA Benchmarking Network: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1435842)

Standards :

Standards for Hospital Libraries 2007:

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2268237/

Articles :

The Value of Hospital Library Benchmarking
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/1021028687-7766837/content~db=all~content=a903922501~frm=titlelink

The Buck Starts Here : Using In-House Reports to Market your Library
http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/content~db=all~content=a902276607

Using standards to make your case: examples from the medical library community
http://www.emeraldinsight.com/journals.htm?articleid=1728032&show=abstract&

Monday, May 17, 2010

A listserv about scholarly communication

If you want to read lively comment, posting, etc. about scholarly communication, you may consider joining the liblicense listserv. The list serve is maintained by Yale and you can sign up at: http://www.library.yale.edu/~llicense/email.shtml

Friday, May 14, 2010

Thursday, April 29, 2010

New OvidSP

Some new features in the latest OvidSP

1. You may switch between Search, Journals, Books, and My Workspace anytime you want without losing the searches you have done under the Search function.

2. The Filter By widget on the right-hand side allows you to filter your results by publication year, subject, author, journal, and publication type. If you would like the filtered results to show up in the Search History area, you can simply click on “Add to Search History” which is underneath “Filter By”.

3. “Keep Selected” feature is nice. After you select the desired results, you just need to click on “Keep Selected” and those selected results will be kept and shown in the Search History area.

4. New results management options: users can export their results to Word document, PDF, text file, Citavi, EndNote, ProCite, Reference Manger, RefWorks, BRS/Tagged, Reprint/Medlars, RIS, or XML.

5. New email features: you may choose to email your results in one of the eight styles: AMA, APA, Chicago (Author,Date), Chicago (Humanities), MLA, Vancouver, Ovid Labled Citation, or Ovid Citation.

6. The “drag-and-drop” feature: To drop it to the desired place, you have to make sure that the red stop icon () has changed into green tick ().

7. The neatest thing is My Workspace. There are four components in My Workspace:

1) My Projects. In My Projects, users can store citations and/or full-text documents they found in Ovid databases, and they can also add citations and upload full-text documents from outside Ovid databases. The maximum storage space for items from outside Ovid is 50 MB. Uploaded files will be kept at Ovid servers. The Upload File function can be turned off if the institution does not want their staff to upload files to servers that are outside of their organization. A project will be moved to Trash a year after its creation date and will be kept in Trash for a month. After that, the project will be deleted permanently. But a notice will be sent to the account owner eleven months after the creation date of the project and the account owner can choose to activate the project to prevent it from being deleted. There are no collaboration features with My Projects for now, but it is something that Ovid will add in the future.

2) My Searches and Alerts. All the saved searches and alerts created in the old version are kept here. You actually can add the auto alerts created in the old version to My Projects if you like.

3) My eTOCs. All the eTOCs created in the old version are kept here.

4) Install Toolbar. You may install the Ovid toolbar from here. I could not install it in my IE, but I was successful with FireFox. The Ovid Toolbar only works after you have logged into the new OvidSP. With Ovid Toolbar, you may add citations and/or full-text documents when you are working with resources that are outside Ovid databases, e.g. PubMed, or the Internet, etc.

There is a side-by-side screen comparison of Old OvidSP and New OvidSP available at:
http://www.ovid.com/site/pdf/side_by_side/sidebysidecomparison-April5_newheader.pdf

If you would like to attend the training sessions, you can find the information at:
http://www.ovid.com/site/resources/training_ovidsp.jsp

Thursday, March 25, 2010

Grey Matters - CADTH

CADTH Workshop
  • The link to CADTH Grey Matters Workshop Webcast:

http://events.startcast.com/events6/Default.aspx?EID=cb7423b7-1be2-482b-848f-a35871639801

To access the Webcast, people need to fill out the registration form first. After the registration form being submitted, the Webcast will open right away.

  • The link to the Grey Matters Checklist:

http://www.cadth.ca/index.php/en/cadth/products/grey-matters